Best two reviews:
1) AllMusic- Patty Griffin is a remarkable portrait of the artist and the experiences that informed these songs, and even by the high standards of her body of work, it's something special and is a potent reminder of her status as one of America's signature singer/songwriters. (Rating: 90) Read Full Review >
2) Austin Chronicle- Wrapping in just under an hour, this ultra tight-knit collection telegraphs timelessness in story and song, a lasting chronicle rooted in folk tradition that sits among Griffin's best work. (Rating: 89) Read Full Review >

Worst two reviews:
3) Glide Magazine- This is one of Griffin’s most introspective albums, as she continues to move in this direction. Her fans will enjoy the lyrics and her, unique passionate vocals. (Rating: 80) Read Full Review >
4) PopMatters- The record's sparse instrumentation (the album was produced by Griffin and her longtime musical partner Craig Ross) enhances the personal nature of the project. It doesn't matter if these songs are literally autobiographical or clearly fictional. She sings them as if they were factual. (Rating: 80) Read Full Review >